A Detailed Comparison for Smart Gift Shoppers

When it comes to thoughtful gifting, two major online platforms stand out—Personalization Mall and Edible Arrangements. Both are widely trusted, widely advertised, and serve millions of customers across the U.S. But which one is actually better for your needs?

In this detailed comparison, we’ll break down what each platform offers, the types of gifts they specialize in, the deals currently available, and how they stack up when it comes to value, convenience, and impact.

Personalization Mall: The Go-To for Customized Keepsakes

About the Platform

Personalization Mall specializes in turning everyday items into personal, meaningful gifts. From embroidered blankets and engraved cutting boards to photo frames and name-etched garden stones, their catalog is full of items that are made unique for each customer.

Best for: 
Milestone gifts, long-term keepsakes, decor with emotional value. 

Current Highlights

  • Father’s Day Deals: Up to 50% off gifts like mugs, picture frames, and BBQ tools. 
  • Graduation Offers: Save up to 50% on custom photo books, ornaments, and jewelry. 
  • Extra Coupons: 
  • SHOP5: $5 off orders over $35 
  • SHOP10: $10 off orders over $50 
  • SHOP15: $15 off orders over $75 
  • SHOP20: $20 off orders over $90 

Pros

  • Deep personalization options (names, photos, dates, messages) 
  • Wide variety of product categories 
  • Frequent sitewide promotions 
  • Most orders ship within 1–2 business days 

Cons

  • No same-day delivery
  • Shipping costs can add up without coupons 

Edible Arrangements: Fresh Gifts for Instant Gratification 

About the Platform: 
Edible Arrangements offers handcrafted fruit bouquets, chocolate-dipped strawberries, cookie boxes, and even flower add-ons. Known for blending presentation with taste, they make a strong case for gifts that are as indulgent as they are beautiful. 

Best for: 
Last-minute gifts, birthdays, celebrations, food lovers. 

Current Highlights

  • Graduation Gift Sets: Featuring dessert platters, fruit boxes, and flower bundles.
  • Free Delivery: On orders over $89 before tax and discounts.

Pros

  • Same-day delivery available in many areas 
  • Broad food gift selection beyond just fruit
  • Can bundle with flowers, plush toys, or greeting cards 

Cons 

  • Limited personalization 
  • Perishable items require prompt delivery and use 
     

Side-by-Side Comparison 

Feature Personalization Mall Edible Arrangements 
Gift Type  Personalized keepsakes  Fruit-based edible gifts 
Customization Level  High – text, names, photos  Low – limited to card or occasion selection 
Delivery Speed  Ships in 1–2 days Same-day available 
Deals & Coupons Multiple tiered codes + 30–50% off sales Free delivery over $89 + special offers page 
Best For Memorable, sentimental gifts Tasty, festive, and quick surprises 
User Experience Organized by occasion, clear personalization steps Easy to browse by theme or location 

Final Thoughts: Which Should You Choose?

Choose Personalization Mall if you’re gifting for an occasion where emotional value and long-term use matter—anniversaries, Father’s Day, weddings, or memorials. The customization options make the gift one-of-a-kind. 

Choose Edible Arrangements if you want your gift to be indulgent, celebratory, and delivered fast—especially for birthdays, graduations, or any last-minute celebration. 

In some cases, the best option is to combine both: send a gourmet fruit box for now and a custom keepsake for the long term. 

Surprise Someone Sweetly – Explore Edible Gifts